The paradox of operational excellence – When the playbook meets reality

By Immanuel BOAMA-WIAFE

Seven years into leading operational transformations across corporate giants and my own ventures, I have stumbled upon a truth you will not find in most management playbooks: the best operational leaders are not those who follow the manual to the letter. They are the ones who know exactly when to toss it out the window.

The duality no one talks about

We live in an era obsessed with standardization. Process maps, SOPs, ISO certifications, workflow automation, and our whole discipline is built on the belief that predictability equals excellence. Do not get me wrong, that foundation is very key. I have seen how enterprise-wide automation can shrink issue detection from days to hours. Structure works. It saves time, money, and yes, our sanity. Here is what keeps me up at night: the same rigid frameworks that create operational excellence can become your biggest liability when reality decides to improvise.

The 99% and The 1%

I have come to see operational management in two modes: the 99percent and the 1percent. The 99percent is where your systems shine. This is where business continuity plans, disaster recovery protocols, and compliance frameworks earn their keep. When things run smoothly, structured approaches boost efficiency, slash recovery times, and make stakeholders smile. This is the operations we plan for, document, and proudly highlight.

Then there is the 1percent where a critical supplier vanishes overnight. When a system fails in ways your disaster recovery plan never imagined. When demand spikes 300percent without warning. When regulations shift beneath your feet. These moments are not in any playbook because they are unpredictable. If you have been in ops long enough, you have felt that chill: the moment you realize your beautiful plan is useless, and you need to figure out something new fast. That 1percent is where true operational leadership is born.

When planning meets chaos

I will never forget scaling my own business while managing a lot of client engagements. We had perfect workflows, clear processes, color-coded everything. I was proud of what we had built. Then a global crisis hit, COVID. Logistics froze and service delivery needed reinventing. Client demands shifted overnight. The playbook used over time became obsolete in hours.

What saved us was not our procedures rather it was the resilience we had impacted into the team, the trust built through consistent leadership, and the freedom we gave people to decide when the manual fell short. We kept our clients not because we followed the plan, but because we had built a team that could rewrite it in real time. That experience taught me more about operations than any certification ever could.

The three pillars of dynamic operations

Through structured transformations and chaotic fires alike, I have found three pillars that bridge planning and reality:

1. Build systems that breathe

Rigid systems break under pressure; flexible systems adapt. Think of it like the difference between the mighty oak and a grove of bamboo in a storm. The oak stands rigid and tall until a strong wind uproots it. The bamboo bends, sways, and springs back. Both are strong, but only one is designed for dynamic, unpredictable forces.

When implementing automated compliance and performance tracking, the goal should not just be efficiency but also be adaptability. Create monitoring with configurable thresholds, flexible reporting structures, and the ability to rapidly incorporate new data sources when the situation demands it. Your operational infrastructure should be like the bamboo: a deep, connected root system (your core principles and data) with flexible joints (your workflows and decision points) that allow you to withstand unexpected pressure without snapping. You need both deep-rooted strength and situational agility, not one at the expense of the other.

2. Cultivate resilient teams, not just compliant ones

I have managed teams from small cores to sprawling cross-functional groups. The difference between teams that crumble and those that thrive is not about following procedures but about improvising while staying true to the goal.

Retention does not come from perfect processes. It comes from building competence and confidence, encouraging smart risk-taking, and fostering trust so people can make judgment calls. You need teams who understand the why behind the what but rather who can look at a broken process and say, “The goal is still X, but the path changed. Let’s figure this out together.”

That thinking does not come from compliance training. It comes from leaders who build capability, not just capacity.

3. Master the art of controlled chaos

Leading in high-pressure, fast-changing environments requires a unique skill: holding strategic clarity while making tactical pivots. This is where experience becomes priceless and where many managers hit their limits. In risk reviews, you will find countless inefficiencies. But fixing them while keeping the lights on? That is what I call “controlled chaos management.”

You are simultaneously:

• Keeping existing operations running
• Implementing improvements
• Fighting new fires
• Managing expectations
• Keeping your team motivated

It has organized improvisation at scale and if you have never done it, it feels more like changing tires while the car’s still moving.

The beautiful balance

Here is why I still love this work after all these years: operational management is both a science and an art. The science gives you the foundation; the frameworks, metrics, and processes that create baseline excellence. It is what you show stakeholders, what gets audited, what lives in reports. It is measurable and non-negotiable.

The art emerges when you navigate the unknown when intuition, team dynamics, and leadership become your primary tools. This is what happens in the war room at 2 AM, when everything is on fire and you are deciding with incomplete information as the clock runs down. The leaders who last are not those who choose one over the other. They build robust systems while keeping the flexibility to transcend them. They plan meticulously while accepting uncertainty. They standardize processes while empowering teams to break rules intelligently. It is a balance. A beautiful, frustrating, endlessly challenging balance.

What this means for you

Whether you are scaling a startup or transforming an enterprise, embrace this duality:

Plan meticulously; Build frameworks, document processes, establish metrics. Invest in systems that create consistent excellence. This is not optional, it is foundational. Your team needs it, your stakeholders expect it, and scaling is impossible without it.

But prepare to improvise brilliantly where  you grow resilient teams. Build adaptive systems. Develop operational intuition through experience because only experience teaches this part. Foster a culture where people understand the why, so they can judge wisely when the playbook does not apply.

The goal is not perfection more sustainable high performance amid uncertainty. It is achieving stellar system availability while handling surprises. It is saving costs through optimization while staying agile enough to pivot.

The bottom line

After years of operational transformation, entrepreneurship, and leading teams through calm and chaos, here is what I know: operational excellence is not about eliminating uncertainty more of  building organizations that can dance with it. The playbook matters. The structures matter. The processes and protocols all matter. But the ability to rewrite them in real time? That matters more.

You will spend 99percent of your time conducting the orchestra, ensuring everyone follows the sheet music for a flawless performance. It is that 1percent when everything goes sideways. That is when you learn whether you have built an operation that only works under perfect conditions or one that can adapt and even thrive when conditions are anything but perfect. That is the paradox, the beauty, and the relentless challenge of operational management. For those of us who thrive where structure meets chaos, it is what makes this work endlessly, deeply human.

>>>the writer is a Certified Information Systems Auditor and Operational Management Lead. He specializes in helping organizations strengthen resilience through standards-based auditing, risk management, and operational assurance

The post The paradox of operational excellence – When the playbook meets reality appeared first on The Business & Financial Times.

Read Full Story